Christmas movies have always been a popular category, with almost every streaming site and entertainment company coming up with all forms of films and shows that revolve around the theme of Christmas. However, not all of these films end up getting rave reviews or becoming popular. Over the past years it has been proven that a Christmas movie is either a hit or a miss, and rarely something in between. It is definitely intriguing to identify which of these Christmas movies made to the nice list, or the “best list”, and which of them made to the naughty list, or the “worst list”. With a little bit of help from Rotten Tomatoes, the two lists have been compiled, and you can find them below. First, the five best-rated, then, the five worst-rated.
The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993) – 95%
This stop-motion animated film by Henry Selick and Tim Burton might have been released over 25 years ago, but it is still loved by every Christmas movie fan. What is interesting about The Nightmare Before Christmas is that it is a perfect transition from the Halloween spirit to Christmas as the movie is an amalgamation of both celebrations. The bright and dark colors and, of course, the unique characters ensure that the viewer does not forget this movie easily. With its legacy still continuing, this particular movie has the perfect ingredients of fantasy and reality, in turn, allowing any child and adult to enjoy it.
It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) – 93%
Frank Capra’s It’s a Wonderful Life is not an easy watch as it takes the viewer on an emotional rollercoaster ride but it is definitely one that is worth watching simply because it captures the true spirit and meaning of Christmas. Regarded as one of the most inspirational films, this holiday classic reminds the viewer that regardless of all the tough lucks and obstacles, life itself is a true gem. With the protagonist being reminded of how important every single individual is, the film ensures that the viewer is comforted and made to feel special. Thus, it has become a tradition for many families to watch this together.
Miracle on 34th Street (1947) (96%)
With one of the best on-screen adaptations of Santa, this 1947 classic adds in a little bit of hope and miracle to the Christmas season. Miracle on 34th Street might focus on a Santa Claus trying to restore the Christmas spirit, but it is also a film that reminds the viewers of the importance of belief. This particular film brings back the age-old debate of whether Santa exists or not. Regardless of the viewer being a child or an adult, it is surely going to light up a spark in favor of the argument of Santa Claus existing.
The Shop Around the Corner (1940) – 100%
A classic romantic comedy, The Shop Around the Corner merges the themes of love and Christmas to bring the viewer a heart-warming film. The story revolves around Klara Novak (Margaret Sullavan) and Alfred Kralik (James Stewart) who, unbeknownst to them, are each other’s mystery correspondents. The film focuses on these two characters’ relationship that starts off on a rough note but ends with a romantic vibe, in turn, restoring the faith in love. The film is yet another classic that focuses on sending positive messages to the viewer.
How the Grinch Stole Christmas (1966) – 100%
While the live-action movie version of Dr. Seuss’ well-known story, which featured Jim Carrey as the Grinch, might be what comes to the minds of many Christmas fans, it is the 1966 animated TV special that ranks as the number one Christmas movie on Rotten Tomatoes. Obviously, the bright colors, the brilliant voice acting of Boris Karloff, and the story itself makes this movie the best holiday movie and is definitely a must-watch for anyone who loves Christmas movies.
An American Carol (2008) – 12%
This film by Davic Zucker attempts to combine politics with Christmas and fails. By using the classic story of A Christmas Carol, the protagonist, Malone’s patriotism is restored. In a nutshell, the film shows how Marlone goes from a left-wing activist to someone who is biased towards right-wing ideologies. There are certain disturbing aspects of the film, like the portrayal of the protagonist’s interviewee, Aziz, as a terrorist in disguise, in turn, focusing on the stereotyping of the Muslim community. Perhaps, the messages the film tries to convey does more harm than good, in turn, taking away the actual spirit of Christmas.
Surviving Christmas (2004) – 8%
Surviving Christmas might have a brilliant set of actors like Ben Affleck, James Gandolfini, Christina Applegate and Catherine O’Hara, but, unfortunately, the film lacks the elements needed to capture the viewer’s attention. In fact, this particular film is regarded as one of Affleck’s low points in terms of his acting career. Of course, the title of the film itself does not sound like Chirstmas-spirit. Where does the film go wrong? While the film tries to show that money can’t buy happiness, the lack of comedy and diversions from the central plot makes it an unexciting film.
Deck the Halls (2006) – 6%
A film that focuses on two characters fighting to show off their Christmas spirit by decorating their houses, Deck the Halls is not exactly new. In fact, Jake Coyle states that the film lacks originality and thus, the humor is quite dry. Even with Danny DeVito and Matthew Broderick taking over the roles of the main characters, the film was unable to excite the viewers. However, the film does attempt to remind the viewer that true Christmas spirit does not lie in the decorations or the fancy ornaments but the film falls short of creating an enticing story that could grab the attention of Christmas movie lovers.
Christmas with the Kranks (2004) – 5%
Based on John Grisham’s novel Skipping Christmas, this Christmas comedy by Joe Roth is yet another mediocre film that fails to bring in joyous Christmas feelings. Rather, the protagonists of the film seem to be more naughty than nice and end up being just plain rude. Even if the film begins with the hopes of turning itself into a merry production with a happy ending, its dry comedy diverts the attention that should have been given to the plot and the Christmas themes. Unfortunately, the inclusion of Tim Allen and Jamie Lee Curtis was not sufficient to save this film from many negative reviews.
The Nutcracker in 3D (2010) – 0%
The Nutcracker in 3D finds itself as the worst Christmas movie ever made. Even though the idea of E.T.A. Hoffmann’s classic story being mixed with modern technology sounds appealing, the film fails to uphold this excitement. In fact, with many critics questioning the choice of music, makeup and the horrible special effects, the film ended up receiving some harsh feedback. This film fails to bring justice to the classic story as its attempt at trying to include an interesting plot ends up with a confusing plot that has too many holes and a lack of a proper flow. Unfortunately, The Nutcracker in 3D is one Christmas movie that is better off unwatched.
