Summary
- Jeff Nichols, the director behind acclaimed dramas like Mud and Midnight Special, had a dark and intense vision for an Aquaman movie.
- Nichols drew inspiration from Peter David’s ’90s narrative, which transformed Aquaman into a grim figure burdened by loss, complete with a harpoon hand.
- This scrapped version of Aquaman promised a deeper exploration of the hero’s haunting past and a more intense portrayal, far removed from the charismatic and light-hearted 2018 blockbuster.
In a revelatory junction where the present meets the path not taken, we find ourselves immersed in the fascinating what-could-have-been narrative of the dark and intense Aquaman movie that never saw the light of day. The landscape of superhero movies might have taken a different, grittier route had Jeff Nichols, the mastermind behind acclaimed dramas such as Mud and Midnight Special, got to helm the 2018 Aquaman movie, steering the iconic DC superhero into uncharted waters.
The ripple effects of the 2014 Sony email hack unearthed the buried initial plans of Nichols potentially directing Jason Momoa in this ambitious Justice League spin-off. Although the directorial reins were eventually handed over to James Wan, who spearheaded the project to a monumental $1.1 billion box office triumph, making it the highest-grossing DC film to date, the echos of Nichols’ vivid and somber vision for Aquaman continue to reverberate.
Nichols recently resurfaced these scrapped plans in an engaging conversation on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, a conversation that originally centered around his latest project, The Bikeriders, starring Jodie Comer and Austin Butler. A director known for his adept craftsmanship in narrating complex, layered stories, Nichols disclosed that his envisioning of Aquaman drew heavily from Peter David’s groundbreaking narrative from the ’90s, which transformed the underwater hero into a grim figure burdened by loss, adorned with a harpoon hand, long hair, and a beard that signified a tragic king in mourning.
Jeff Nichols’ Aquaman: A Deep Dive into Darkness
Reflecting on the pitch that never came to fruition, Nichols reminisced:
“I still have scenes from [Aquaman] in my head that would’ve been good. They would’ve been quite different from the film that was made.”
His voice tinged with a hint of nostalgia, he added:
“It wasn’t ever feasible… I liked the older Aquaman, like when he had a harpoon for a hand. He was a fallen king and his son had died. He was in mourning.”
The director’s vision promised a deeper exploration of a hero grappling with haunting past transgressions, a portrayal far removed from the charismatic and light-hearted version portrayed in the 2018 blockbuster.
David, the original architect of this darker rendition of Aquaman in the comics, had envisaged a radical transformation for the character back in the ’90s. He replaced Aquaman’s missing hand with a golden harpoon following a brutal encounter with the villain Charybdis, and introduced Koryak, Aquaman’s illegitimate son with Kako, an Inuit woman. This makeover wasn’t just aesthetic but significantly altered the hero’s presence and aura.
During an interview in 2018, David articulated his vision, emphasizing the gravity he wanted the new Aquaman to convey. “I wanted that kind of gravity to his appearance — so that when this guy walked into a room — you KNEW he was a bad-ass. He was NOT someone you wanted to screw with,” David asserted. This bold reimagination was designed to make Aquaman’s entrance into any space a momentous event, with his gravitas demanding respect and evoking a sense of awe.
As we stand on the cusp of another addition to the Aquaman series, with Momoa reprising his role in Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom, slated for a December 20th release, we can’t help but ponder on the alternate cinematic universe that Nichols envisioned — a universe rich with darker nuances and a more intense portrayal of the beloved aquatic hero.
While Nichols jests that his version might have only “sold hundreds of dollars worth of tickets,” his unique perspective on this iconic character offers a tantalizing glimpse into a more complex, mature, and perhaps even tragic world within the DC universe — a glimpse of a journey that promises substance over spectacle, depth over dazzle, beckoning audiences to dive into the unexplored depths of Aquaman’s soul, where darkness meets the deep blue sea.
