When this moment happened: Season 10, Episode 12: “Beach, Don’t Kill My Vibe”
James gasps, “AH! AH!” and runs out of the room (tripping on a table on his way out) to “wash 151 out of his eye.” Later we find out from the waitress that the middle part — aka the part that got in his eye — is just for decoration and does not actually have any alcohol. Incredible performance nonetheless.