Before starring in movies and shows like Napoleon Dynamite and Veronica Mars, Tina Majorino was a bonafide child star in the ’90s. It seemed like at least 40% of the time I turned on my TV, there she was, in movies like When a Man Loves a Woman, Waterworld, and Corrina, Corrina. Between this and her soft-spoken, subtle approach to acting, I think she would’ve been a great pick for Eleven.