#6 – The Insurgent Impersonator
She runs a €2 billion incumbent like a €20 million challenger. The target contains forty-seven people, including three at the agency; niche activations are labelled best practices, and generate negligible revenue. Great marketing for the wrong category is a variant of what this toxic CMO does, with the agility of an insurgent brand, of course.
#7 – The Youth Worshipper
For this CMO, there are only two consumer segments: 18–25 and… ‘dying’. Every brand must rejuvenate and borrow codes from consumers who may neither want nor afford it. Existing buyers are boring, and feel unwelcome. “Investing in the future” sounds better than admitting the target resembles the marketing department: young, urban, university-educated and impeccably progressive.
#8 – The Order Taker
He hears from markets and sales teams, absorbs nothing, then says: “Let’s do it.” Sales gets its annual innovation; markets get new campaigns, ad hoc research and flavor innovations. Strategy becomes a Christmas tree. Stakeholder satisfaction passes for alignment; saying no should often be part of brand stewardship, but, to this kind of toxic CMO, yes looks more like inclusive leadership.
#9- The Apologetic Marketer
He suspects Sales is doing the real work. It has customers, orders and this month’s numbers, while Marketing only has future demand and buzzwords. Because he feels like an impostor, and to feel concrete and useful, this CMO volunteers budgets for promotions and gap-closing plans until marketing becomes sales stimulation with a better name. The inferiority complex becomes strategy.
#10 – The Ivory Tower King
Collaboration begins once the work is finished. Initiatives are developed by this CMO alone, in a silo, with no input on local or commercial needs. They are then unveiled at a conference, choreographed as a coronation. In Queen Bee form, one strategic brain surrounds itself with workers confined to execution and agreement. Questions signal resistance; applause means alignment.
#11 – The Lucky Genius
I said 10, but in marketing, we love “buy X, get one free” offers. So here is number 11.
This lucky CMO launches his campaign as the category accelerates, a competitor stumbles or distribution expands. Sales rise; the campaign caused everything. Weak at diagnosis but gifted at attribution, he turns tailwinds into brilliance and luck into best practice. He becomes the first believer in their own propaganda.
So who is to blame for the toxic CMO?
It’s easy to laugh at these characters and tell companies to hire better. But these poisonous characters are not merely recruited; they are produced. Companies often reward visible action. Launch something and there are presentations, milestones and applause. Quiet brand stewardship doesn’t reap the same reward at most companies.
Meanwhile, the CFO wants returns; Sales wants something new for customers; the CEO wants agility; Local markets insist their consumers are different; Boards demand the company stake a visionary AI plan. The CMO is left in a double bind. They have to be bold yet risk-aware, visionary yet inclusive, locally responsive yet globally consistent, commercially minded yet consumer centric, committed to the long term yet immediately accountable. No wonder the resulting creature sometimes looks slightly deranged. The job description already was.

